Is it possible for Western individualists to even think ethically any more? Peter Bolt

This is a point worth reflecting on deeply. 

It is at the core of what I repeatedly encountered when doing my study and writing on forgiveness.  Biblically, forgiveness is something that happens between two parties.

But, in current western thought, forgiveness is a feeling.  It is no longer seen ethically.  Rather, forgiveness is needed so that we don’t feel bitter.  In Embodying Forgiveness, Jones calls this “therapeutic forgiveness.”

Dianne Howard08/05/2008 12:10 PM

Peter,
if this is the case (I am not disputing it) what are the implications for how we ‘converse’ with society?

Have read a few things this week which caused me to reflect.

In each example church was speaking publicly to its society:

1. Church advised its local community to be more gracious…

2. Marriage (male/female) is best for society……

3. Society please be less greedy so we don’t global over heat……

What is the place of christian ethics when speaking to a non-christian audience?

My perspective is that Western Society has moved from “moral code” ethics to an ethical philosophy where “right” is seen as “freedom, liberty and choice” and “wrong” as “slavery, oppression and restriction”.  Therefore, I think our society does have an ethical code on which our society is being built, but it is an ethical code made up of radically different values.

If I’m right, there are a couple of interesting points that follow:

1) The Bible itself agrees that liberty is good and oppression is bad.  These are not the primary factors that Christians understand to define “good” and “bad”, but they do provide a shared basis from which we can “converse with society” (albeit with limitations).

2) Young Christians have imbibed and live by these values also, hence the big push for social justice in many parts of the Church (not that there was none before).  Where the values of freedom, liberty and choice do not line up with Biblical values, there is a huge tension that many don’t know what to do with, or even why it exists.

I’m not certain, but I’m fairly sure a similar shifts in ethics have happened historically in other societies.  It’d be interesting to check out.

Commenting rules

If you would like your comment to be considered for publication, please observe the following rules:

  1. Please use your full name (your real name, not an alias).
  2. Stay on topic.
  3. Be godly.

Failure to adhere to these rules will result in your comment being quietly deleted.

If you want to give us feedback but don't want your comments to appear on the blog, DON'T use the form below. Instead, please send us an email or click on the button below.

Your Comment

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments

The Art of Living
Briefing cover

The Sola Panel

The Briefing

Current issue

The strategy of God

Recent comments

RSS logo

Scott Tubman on "We are poorly dressed" - Part 2 (20/08/2008).

Ian Carmichael on Sola Gratia - Tahlia's story (20/08/2008).

Cathy McKay on "We are poorly dressed" - Part 2 (20/08/2008).

Gordon Cheng on An interview with Mark Thompson (20/08/2008).

Martin Kemp on The indivisibility of truth (20/08/2008).

Andrew Barry on "We are poorly dressed" - Part 2 (20/08/2008).

Scott Tubman on "We are poorly dressed" - Part 2 (19/08/2008).

Scott Tubman on "We are poorly dressed" - Part 2 (19/08/2008).

Alex Phillips on A freebie for you: Jonah in the ESV (19/08/2008).

Nicole Starling on "We are poorly dressed" - Part 2 (19/08/2008).

Recent posts

RSS logo

An interview with Mark Thompson by Sandy Grant (1 comment). Today we interview Mark Thompson... Mark, how did you come to Christ? I first heard the gospel … more

Sola Gratia - Tahlia’s story by Lionel Windsor (4 comments). Tahlia was born addicted to heroin, thanks to her mum Shae’s addiction. Tahlia (not her real name) lives with … more

“We are poorly dressed” - Part 2 by Nicole Starling (9 comments). Thanks to everyone who contributed comments in answer to the question that I raised in my previous … more

The indivisibility of truth by Tony Payne (4 comments). This Saturday’s classic Briefing extract is about the indivisibility of truth. It’s from Briefing #8, August 1, 1988: If … more

Dread, joy and Morning Prayer by Tony Payne (5 comments). Standing on the 5th tee at St Michael’s, in Sydney’s East, the golfer experiences a mixture of nervousness and dread. Here … more

A freebie for you: Jonah in the ESV by Gordon Cheng (10 comments). Here at Matthias Media, we read and recommend the English Standard Version Bible, the ESV, as a superior … more

‘We are poorly dressed…’ - Part 1 by Nicole Starling (15 comments). “We are poorly dressed… Be imitators of me.” (1 Cor 4:11, 16) “All her household are clothed in … more

Where’s your ministry ‘AT’? by Ben Pfahlert (11 comments). Christians and soldiers have a lot in common, or at least they should (2 Tim 2:3-4). Firstly they both know that … more

Countering Nowism by Lionel Windsor (2 comments). It’s been interesting to follow the comments on Tony’s post about the … more

The evangelical inferiority complex by Tony Payne (3 comments). It’s Saturday. Must be time for another classic snippet from the early days of The Briefing, this time about evangelicalism’s … more