Engaging with Barth Gordon Cheng

In every essay that I have critiqued Barth’s position on something (election, revelation etc), the marker’s response was that I simply hadn’t understood Barth’s position! Compared to Barth’s planet-sized brain, I’m admittedly a little-minded man, and so I look forward to reading a expert critique of his theology ... which I can quote in future essays wink

I think the quotes you mentioned highlight some of the key areas of concern conservative evangelicals will normally have about Barth - election, atonement, scripture.
Whilst he is someone that those in ministry and theological training need to be aware of and prepared to engage, I’m often surprised that orthodox reformed folk are quick to recommend, endorse and encourage reading his work. It’s almost done in a type of pseudo intellectual pride! This is not a case of eating a chicken - ie take the meat and throw out the bones - more like negotiating a very bony fish - you’re not likely to take a single mouthful without getting a sharp and dangerous bone stuck in your throat.

Perhaps, as you mention at the end of your articule, this work will help clarify and challenge some of those who have been a little too taken, IMHO, by Barth. I look forward to the Briefing review.

Dear Gordon,

Thanks for the post. Barth is a big mind that entices left-brainers; people love him because he is intellectually stimulating. However, when it comes to (1) following the Bible and (2) giving people something for ministry in the real world, I’m still trying to figure out how he is of use.

Blessings.

Gordon,

Great post! And helpful quotes too - thanks.  Being a Moore college student who hears Barth’s name flying about from time to time, I took and up read a few books about him last year, and am reading through his Evangelical Theology at the moment.  Engaging Barth has certainly been a very helpful book indeed for getting my head around him, and I think it’s great to give this book attention in The Briefing - so thanks!

In Christ (in the Reformed, non-Barthian sense!),
Mark

The subtext of this book seems to be that Barth is a false teacher and a confuser of many. So if what people have written in it helps people to name Barth for what he is, it has served us well not just for exposing him as a fool, but for showing one way in which the study of theology can be turned to good effect.

Oh, and Mark Barry, if you submit such a comment it clearly demonstrates that you haven’t understood Barth correctly.

I am told this is a problem, but I haven’t yet seen why. If you haven’t understood a confusing person correctly, is it possible to raise the possibility that they are a confusing person?

Thanks for drawing attention to my deficient understanding Gordon wink

And what’s the deal with your tacky emoticons? They make my comments seem even dumber than they are actually are smile

They are funny little thingies aren’t they.

I haven’t worked out yet how many variations there are.

smile wink

Commenting rules

If you would like your comment to be considered for publication, please observe the following rules:

  1. Please use your FULL NAME (your real name, not an alias).
  2. Stay on topic.
  3. Be godly.

Failure to adhere to these rules will result in your comment being quietly deleted.

If you want to give us feedback but don't want your comments to appear on the blog, DON'T use the form below. Instead, please send us an email or click on the button below.

Your Comment

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.
Islam in our backyard: A novel argument

Sponsors

Placeholder

Recent comments

RSS logo

Jean Williams on 10 in 2

Jean Williams on 10 in 2

Jean Williams on 10 in 2

Ben Pfahlert on 10 in 2

Nathan on 10 in 2

Current discussions

RSS logo

10 in 2 (6 comments)

Top 10 Tips for Sleep Deprived Prayer (4 comments)

Taking ‘crazy’ one step closer to ‘can do’ (2 comments)

Stress-throwers and stress-absorbers (0 comments)

Recent posts

RSS logo RSS logo

10 in 2 by Ben Pfahlert (6 comments). In January 2010 I set myself a goal that has transformed my diary, my thinking, my reading and the … more

Taking ‘crazy’ one step closer to ‘can do’ by Guest blogger (2 comments). Guest blogger Mikey Lynch, one of the directors of The Geneva Push, talks about the network's approach to … more

Top 10 Tips for Sleep Deprived Prayer by Jennie Baddeley (4 comments). There are so many reasons for losing sleep it's not really worth listing them. You're either getting enough sleep or you're … more

Stress-throwers and stress-absorbers by Jean Williams (0 comments). Are you a stress-thrower or a stress-absorber? A stress-thrower blames things on others and expresses stress in anger; a … more

‘Missional Lifestyle’: Education by Nicole Starling (11 comments). This is the fifth in Nicole's series on ‘missional lifestyle’. Read parts 1, 2, 3 … more

Why do we pray for others? by Scott Newling (1 comment). Learning to pray for others is one of the first things we learn as Christians: we see it commended … more

Forgiveness and repentance (part 8): Does God only forgive us when we repent? (ii) by Mark Baddeley (17 comments). (Read parts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7.) Does … more

The power of example by Peter Sholl (3 comments). Mexico in the 1940s was a country trying to come to grips with the 20th century. While discoveries of oil and … more

Forgiveness and repentance (part 7): Does God only forgive us when we repent? (i) by Mark Baddeley (29 comments). (Read parts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6.) We have been … more

The gospel to Greeks by Karen Beilharz (0 comments). For the past three Saturdays, we've been looking at contributions to the old Briefing ‘People in Ministry’ column, … more

Ministry partners